Restaurants in Butler, IN Back to Cities In IndianaCuisine TypesView AllAmericanBar & GrillBowling AlleyCoffeeFast FoodSandwichTruck Stop Broadway Cafe223 S Broadway St$Butler Bowl & Recreation Center634 E Main St$$Butler One Stop537 W Main St$$Cupbearer Cafe111 S Broadway St$$McDonald’s533 W Main St$Route 6 Bar and More110 W Main St$Subway503 W Main St$