Restaurants in Carthage, IL Back to Cities In IllinoisCuisine TypesView AllBar & GrillFast FoodIce CreamMexicanRestaurantSandwichWine Dairy Queen415 Buchanan St$Hardee’s123 N Madison St$Lake Hill Winery1822 E Co Rd 1540$$Lilly’s Sweet Shop499 Wabash Ave$$MJ’s Bar & Grill1390 Buchanan St$$Sandra’s Authentic Mexican Food225 Buchanan St$$Subway500 Buchanan St$The Dirty Bird Bar and Grill2130 US Hwy 136$$Wood Inn415 Main St$