Restaurants in Clayton, NM Back to Cities In New MexicoCuisine TypesView AllAmericanCafePizzaSandwichTruck Stop 87 Restaurant803 S 1st St$$Godfather’s Pizza703 S 1st St$$Love’s Travel Stop703 S 1st St$$Mock’s Crossroads Coffee Mill2 S Front St$Pizza Hut312 S 1st St$Subway1406 S 1st St$