Restaurants in Elmer, NJ Back to Cities In New JerseyCuisine TypesView AllAmericanDeliDinerIce CreamItalianPizza Elmer Diner Restaurant41 Front St$Elmer Twist148 Chestnut St$Mannino’s Pizza Palace205 Front St$$Papa Luigi119 N Main St$Pittsgrove Deli & Grocery1031 Centerton Rd$$Ye Olde Centerton Inn1136 Almond Rd$$