Restaurants in Jay, OK Back to Cities In OklahomaCuisine TypesView AllAmericanCafeFast FoodMexicanPizzaSandwich Casey’s1014 S Main St$El Vallarta Mexican Restaurant209 S Main St$J-Way Cafe2005 S Main St$McDonald’s404 N Main St$Nana’s Cafe747 S Main St$Pizza HutUS-59$Simple Simon’s Pizza907 N Main St$Sonic Drive-In1226 S Main St$Subway448 S Main St$