Restaurants in Matlacha, FL Back to Cities In FloridaCuisine TypesView AllAmericanBar & GrillBarbecueBreakfastRestaurantSeafood Bert’s Bar & Grill4271 Pine Island Rd$Blue Dog Bar & Grill4597 Pine Island Rd$$Miceli’s Restaurant3930 Pine Island Rd$$Olde Fish House Marina4530 Pine Island Rd$$THAT BBQ PLACE4590 Pine Island Rd$$The Perfect Cup4548 Pine Island Rd$Yucatan Waterfront Bar and Grill4875 Pine Island Rd$$