Restaurants in Mayfield, NY Back to Cities In New YorkCuisine TypesView AllCafeCoffeeDinerItalianPizzaSandwichTakeout Dunkin’2470 NY-30$Lanzi’s on the Lake Restaurant & Marina1751 NY-30$$Mama Mia’s of Mayfield2469 NY-30$$Mister Pizza7 N School St$Nanny & Pop’s Small Town Cafe20 School St$Northampton Diner1205 NY-30$Subway2470 NY-30$