Restaurants in New Middletown, OH Back to Cities In OhioCuisine TypesView AllAmericanCoffeeIce CreamPizzaSandwich Cocca’s Pizza10829 Main St$Dairy Queen10201 Main St$Golden Rye Grille10745 Main St$Hallowed Grounds Coffee Co.13.5 Sycamore Dr$$Subway10651 Main St$