Restaurants in Sheffield, MA Back to Cities In MassachusettsCuisine TypesView AllAmericanBakeryBreweryPizzaPubRestaurantWine Bakin’ Bakery117 Main St$$Big Elm Brewing65 Silver St$$Roberto’s Pizza113 Main St$$Sunset Meadow of Massachusetts296 S Main St$$The Frog Restaurant650 N Main St$$The Marketplace Kitchen and Cafe18 Elm Ct$$The Stagecoach Tavern at Race Brook Lodge854 S Undermountain Rd$$