Restaurants in Summerland Key, FL Back to Cities In FloridaCuisine TypesView AllCoffeeConvenience StorePizzaSeafood A Slice of Paradise24458 Overseas Hwy$Dion’s Quik Chik24996 Overseas Hwy$Island Coffee House24437 Overseas Hwy$Mangrove Mama’s19991 Overseas Hwy$$Tonio’s Seafood Shack & Tiki Bar25163 Overseas Hwy$$