Restaurants in Sylvan Beach, NY Back to Cities In New YorkCuisine TypesView AllFamilyGas StationItalianPizzaSeafood Canal View Cafe9 Canal St$$Captain John’s RestaurantOPEN APR. TO OCT. Holidays at Noon 1424 Main Street$$Circle K1510 Main St$$Eddie’s901 Main St$$Pizza King and Grill404 Main St$