Restaurants in Wantage, NJ Back to Cities In New JerseyCuisine TypesView AllBagelBarCoffeeDeliJapanesePizzaRestaurant Brothers Pizza & Italian Restaurant455 NJ-23 #4$Cow Patty’s154 NJ-23$$Dunkin’190 NJ-23$Scarsella’s Italian Deli & Restaurant285 NJ-23 NORTH$Skylands Craft Beer & Wine Garden447 NJ-284$The Bagel Tree205 NJ-23$Up the creek cafe1214 St 1214 NJ-23 Building B$$Yamato Hibachi Steakhouse205 NJ-23$$