Restaurants in Water Mill, NY Back to Cities In New YorkCuisine TypesView AllFrenchGreekMexicanSushi Bistro Ete760 Montauk Hwy$$$Calissa Hamptons1020 Montauk Hwy$$$Kissaki Sushi670 Montauk Hwy Suite E$$Sabrosa Mexican Grill1152 Montauk Hwy$